Update for 2013: The Geico card has been discontinued. Here are some good replacements I recommend, depending on your credit score/history:
(By the way you can pay your GEICO auto insurance policy with whatever credit card you want)
If you have a good cash back credit card, you can spend the cash rebate on anything you want… including your GEICO auto insurance policy. So your best bet is to go with a no annual fee card that has extremely high cash back.
GEICO Credit Card Review (discontinued - I'm leaving this up for reference only)
As you may already be aware, there’s not that much information floating around online about this credit card. In fact, their website for the card doesn’t really have anything on it except a login box (for current users). I didn’t see any advertisements for it, not even GEICO credit card application. However, I was able to find a terms & conditions document which was help in revealing how this credit card’s rewards actually work…
The GEICO Platinum MasterCard gives its cardmembers “Gecko Dollars” for their spending. Here’s what they normally give:
- 3% on the first $150 in gas purchases per billing cycle (and 1% after that)
- 1% on all other spending
The GEICO credit card charges a $48.00 annual fee. This is extremely disappointing. The rewards are only average to begin with, so to be slapped an annual fee on top of that only adds insult to injury. When you think about it, if you’re only getting 1% on your spending, that means you have to spend $4,800 just to pay for the annual fee on the card (or in other words, you aren’t making a penny until you spend at least $4,800).
I don’t have the card myself, but I did check with an affiliate I work with to find reviews. The result? I saw one negative complaint after another about the GEICO credit card. Reportedly, many people are extremely unhappy with their customer service. One person even said they were surprised that GEICO would even want to be associated with such a card, some others allege it's a "scam." Many complaints talked about alleged interest rate and credit limit problems. Whatever the case, the general consensus seemed to be clear: allegedly the GEICO Platinum MasterCard has poor customer service.
I am a huge fan of Warren Buffett and his companies, but this credit card really puzzles me. Warren aims to deliver value to his customers, and I don’t see how the GEICO credit card does that at all. First of all, it has a pitiful rewards program that isn’t really any better than every other credit card on the market. Secondly, they charge nearly fifty dollars for an annual fee. Considering the sub-par rewards and alleged poor customer service, I don’t know who would pay for this card.
Good Replacement Cards?