Q: Is FreeCreditScore.com safe and really free? Or is it just another scam to separate you from your hard-earned money?
A: That question was part of an email I received from a reader. Read my FreeCreditScore.com review to find out the real deal behind this company…
Is FreeCreditScore.com the same as FreeCreditReport.com?
Different websites, same company. A couple years ago the Federal Trade Commission cracked down on the marketing of “free” credit reports and that basically messed up the whole marketing mojo behind FreeCreditReport.com.
So what did they do? Well these days they focus on FreeCreditScore.com instead, since the FTC hasn’t cracked the whip on free scores [yet]. That’s why the old band went bye-bye and the new website uses a totally different group. It’s not “free” unless you cancel within the 7 day trial and doing that, according to customer reviews, can be quite a tedious process.
If you want a truly free score without any hidden tricks, Barclays gives real FICO scores for free to active cardholders of this MasterCard:
Obviously the biggest complaint about the first website was the people felt they were getting duped by the claim that the credit reports were free. Are these credit score offers operated the same way? Sort of.
When you signup, you get a 7 day trial in their credit score monitoring service. Now if you cancel before the trial is up, it really is free… you won’t pay anything. However if you forget, then after your 7 days are up you will be billed $14.95 per month for the service.
Something important to note is what’s in the fine print:
“The credit monitoring benefit may only be available for 5 days during your trial period since enrollment can take up to 2 days.”
That means you can’t confuse the date the benefit starts with the enrollment period. When counting the 7 days, to play it safe it would be best to count from the same day/time you sign-up for the offer. If you enroll, make sure you cancel within that time.
Is it accurate?
Personally, I don’t really have a problem with how they structure the 7 day trial because automatic enrollment without cancellation is pretty typical for any type of service trial out there. However what I do have a problem with is the accuracy of their offer.
Is FreeCreditScore.com accurate? Well, I guess that depends on what your definition of “accurate” is. You see they don’t give you a FICO score but rather something different called the Experian Plus Score (sidenote: Experian owns the FreeCreditScore website).
Unlike FICO, this Plus Score is NOT used by lenders. It even says it right in the website’s fine print:
FICO runs on a scale of 300 to 850. Meanwhile the PLUS score runs from 330 to 830. Some people call these imitators FAKOs because the difference from a FICO can be quite dramatic. Sure, they will still help you gauge where you stand with your creditworthiness, but you can’t use them for an apples-to-apples comparison.For example, if you ask a mortgage broker “Will this Plus Score of mine qualify me for the mortgage?” or ask on this forum “Is my Plus Score good enough for that credit card?” you will probably receive responses of bewilderment.
Rather than comparing apples to oranges, wouldn’t you much rather do an apples-to-apples and learn your real FICO score?
Worth it or not?
FreeCreditScore.com is technically not a “scam” or “ripoff” because they give you exactly what they advertise. Of course, some people don’t read things though before they signup, so they have no idea they are getting a FAKO instead of a FICO, nor are they aware they have to cancel a FreeCreditScore.com membership to keep it truly free. But the truth is all of that is disclosed on their website if you read it.
There is really almost no reason to consider this free trial offer. It’s also definitely not worth paying $14.95 to use it as a long-term credit monitoring service. I’m sure it will probably be adequate for notifying you when new things positively or negative affect your credit but at the end of the day, why pay $14.95/month for that when you aren’t even getting your actual FICO score?!
Instead my recommendation would be to sign-up for a service which actually gives you the genuine FICO score. In reality, there are only two websites which sell true FICO scores directly to consumers: Equifax and MyFICO. Everyone else out there is selling FAKOs.If you want a score that’s not used by lenders, then by all means signup for the FreeCreditScore.com free trial. But in my opinion the much better option would be to apply for a no annual fee Discover it Card, Chase Slate or the Barclaycard MasterCard that gives provides you with your genuine FICO score each and every month on your billing statement for absolutely no cost. And, American Express just announced that they too will begin offering free FICO credit scores with all of their cards as well.. That’s an incredible deal when you think of it given what it costs to actually buy your score from one of these other sites. Plus it’s very convenient to see it every months and monitor and understand what your spending and payment behavior does to your score.
Other sites for free credit scores
|Comparing sites that offer free credit scores/reports|
|Free score types||Free credit report?||Frequency of score/report updates||Explanation of score factors||Free credit monitoring||Credit score prediction/simulator tool?|
|Credit Karma||VantageScore 3.0 from TransUnion and Equifax||YES. From TransUnion and Equifax||Every 7 days||YES||YES, via TransUnion||YES|
|Credit Sesame||VantageScore 3.0 from TransUnion.||NO. Can pay per viewing ($9.95 for TransUnion report) or via monthly subscription (starts at $7.95/month for monthly access to TransUnion, Equifax and Experian reports).||Monthly||YES||YES, via TransUnion||NO|
|Quizzle||VantageScore 3.0 from TransUnion.||YES. TransUnion report.||Every three months (every month for paid accounts)||YES||NO. Can pay for monitoring plan (starts at $8/month)||NO|
|My.CreditCards.com||VantageScore 3.0 from TransUnion||YES. TransUnion report.||Monthly||YES||YES, via TransUnion||NO|
|Credit.com||Vantage 3.0 from Experian; Experian National Equivalency Score||No. Must sign up for access to Experian report with Experian CreditWorks ($1 for 7-day trial, then $21.95/month)||Monthly||YES||NO. Requires paid plan.||NO|
|Mint.com||Equifax Credit Score (proprietary model used by Equifax)||NO. Can get Equifax credit report via Mint Credit Monitor ($16.99/month).||Quarterly score. Monthly for paid subscribers. Monthly credit report via Mint Credit Monitor (paid)||YES||NO. Three-bureau monitoring via Mint Credit Monitor.||NO|
|Wise Piggy||VantageScore 3.0 from TransUnion||NO. Provides “Account Summary”||Monthly||YES||NO||NO|
|Lending Tree||VantageScore 3.0 from TransUnion||NO||Monthly||YES||NO||NO|
|Capital One's CreditWise (for Capital One cardholders only)||VantageScore 3.0 from TransUnion||YES (TransUnion)||Every 7 days||YES|
|Discover's Scorecard||FICO score (Experian)||NO||Every 30 days||YES|
|Chase's Credit Journey||VantageScore 3.0 from TransUnion||NO||Weekly||YES|
Written or last updated February 2016