Well I decided to go ahead and pull the trigger on the Fidelity Amex application I had been planning. I decided today for a few reasons.
1. My balance transfer from my Amex Platinum to my Penfed PRV had gone through and reported to credit bureaus.
2. My new Penfed card existence has not reported to credit bureaus yet (outside of the initial HP)
3. FIA Card Services, which controls the Fidelity Amex and my current BofA Cash Rewards card should have my current BofA card balance even though the balance transfer with that card to Penfed hasn't reported to the credit bureaus yet.
I was approved over the phone for a $17.5K CL. I asked them to round that to an even $20K and they said they would get back to me.
So to recap:
As of 1/16/2013:
BofA World Mastercard ($13.5K CL)
Chase Slate ($13.5K CL)
BofA Cash Rewards Mastercard ($20K CL)
Chase Freedom ($25K CL)
Fidelity Amex ($17.5K CL at least)
Still on the conquer list:
US Bank Cash + (wife app)
Discover IT (wife app)
Amex BCP (I'll probably do this, maybe today...they wouldn't turn down a Platinum card holder, would they?)