I finally decided to register here after lurking around for awhile, mainly because I have an update to this post. Apologies for dead thread bumping.
I can confirm that it is possible to PC from a regular Amex Blue to the Amex EveryDay card, as I literally just did so over the phone 5 minutes ago.
Not only that, but I was told that the EveryDay card was the only option I had if I wanted to PC my Blue. Like the above posts, it was really a no-brainer. They are basically identical products, except ED offers bonus categories for MR points.
I don't know if they have some internal flowchart for PC, but here are some details that may or may not have influenced their decision, just in case:
- Member for 8+ years
- Never PC'd before
- Perfect payment history
- $0 balance at time of PC
- Have never requested a CLI (they offered one during this call)
- This is my only AMEX card